Cranberry Pistachio Biscotti

Compared to other holiday cookies, cranberry pistachio biscotti (or rather any biscotti) is my preferred dessert. Why? Because of the unbelievable combination of flavors. The biscotti are bright from the lemon, magnificent from the cranberry, and phenomenal from the pistachios.

The chewy yet crunchy dessert begs for a cup of coffee or tea. And if you’re not feeling the cranberry or pistachio, pack the biscotti with your preferred flavor: chocolate, another nut, mocha, or more. The recipe remains the same. 

Jump to

Biscotti recipe

Cutting without breaking

Serving and storing

Substitutions and variations

Additional holiday recipes

What is biscotti?

Biscotti are Italian biscuits. They take their name from the Latin word ‘biscoctus.’ When translated to English, it means twice-cooked, and that’s what we do in the recipe. We bake the dough two times, first as a log and then as sliced biscotti. This gives them a firm, crunchy texture and a shelf life that lasts a long time.

How to make cranberry pistachio biscotti?

Making biscotti needs no special skills. The recipe is rather forgiving, something I learned while baking my mocha gingerbread biscotti three years back. 

However, it will take time, if it’s warm in your corner of the world. Because it’s cold here, I don’t need to refrigerate the dough to firm it up. My recipe is straightforward: combine, shape, bake, cut, and bake again.

• Start by making two flax eggs (or beating eggs, your choice) and setting them aside for at least 10 minutes.
• In a new bowl, sift all-purpose flour with baking powder.
• Separately, beat raw sugar with butter until it's fluffy, light, and pale yellow.
• The flax egg should be thick and goopy by now; whisk it into the beaten mixture along with vanilla extract, pure lemon oil, and the zest of one whole lemon. 
• When everything is well combined, use your wooden spatula to fold in the dry ingredients. 
• Stir in chopped cranberries and pistachios.

Bake biscotti logs

• Once all the ingredients are mixed, you’ll have a soft, pliable dough (my biscotti dough is not sticky).
• If the dough doesn’t form, lightly flour your hands and bring it together. 
• Cut the dough in half and then shape each half into a flattened log. 
• Place the logs, spaced apart, on a baking tray lined with parchment paper or Silpat.
• Bake the logs for 25 to 30 minutes till firm and golden.

How to cut biscotti logs without breaking them?

• Let the baked logs cool completely. This is essential. Warm-baked logs are crumbly, and when you slice into them, they break. I always save the crumbly bits and bake them along with the biscotti. They’re delicious, so why throw them?
• Cut cooled logs in half-inch-thick slices.

Double bake the cranberry pistachio biscotti

• Place each slice on the baking tray, making sure the cut side faces down. 
• Bake a second time until the biscotti are crisp, about 10 to 12 minutes.
• Transfer to a rack and let them cool completely before you serve or store. 

Serving holiday biscotti with pistachio and cranberry

Personally, I love to see the green and red peeping from the biscotti sides. So, I don’t think they need any additional garnishing. The light, crunchy, and tart biscotti are ready for dunking.

But if you’re baking these especially for the holidays, or for Christmas gifting, make them more festive: 

• Dip half of each biscotto in melted white chocolate.
• Sprinkle chopped cranberries and pistachios.

What is the best way to store biscotti?

Biscotti have an epic shelf life. They’ll last well for almost a month, making them the best holiday cookie to make ahead. Keep them in an air-tight jar.

What else can you use in the cranberry pistachio biscotti recipe?

Eggs: I used flax eggs, but if all you have in the pantry are regular eggs, then by all means use them. Include what is easy for you; the biscotti will be crispy and buttery with both. 

Flour: Try whole-wheat or half-and-half of all-purpose and whole wheat flour. Adding a portion of almond flour, about 1/4th cup, will give the biscotti a nutty flavor. 

Vegan: I’m not sure coconut oil will suit the crispy texture of the recipe, so stick to plant-based butter.

Revel in all sorts of biscotti variations

The basic biscotti recipe is like a blank canvas; you can add, remove, or swap any of the ingredients. Pander to your taste and palate. 

Oil and zest: Pure lemon oil is optional, but you do not want to miss the zest. This recipe is a testament to what a lemon can do. It shines an incredibly fantastic flavor, making the biscotti more aromatic.

When you open the oven, the heady, citrusy aroma enlivens the entire house. If you couldn’t tell, I really recommend not skipping the lemon zest. In its place, you can add orange zest. 

Cranberries: Figs or dried cherries are brilliant replacements. Raisins are another option, but for me, they do change the flavor profile.

Pistachios: Almonds, cashews, or pecans all make excellent nut substitutions.

White chocolate: I’m not a fan of white chocolate. Give me dark, and I’m happy as a clamp. But even I have to accept that white chocolate chips make the flavor heavenly and lend decadence. Just make sure it’s good quality baking chocolate. 

Give these cranberry pistachio biscotti a shot. They’re:

Zesty

Crunchy

Ideal to wrap as a gift

Wonderful for add-ins

Fabulous for the Holidays

Scalable, halve or double the recipe

More holiday recipes

Dark Chocolate Bark

Strawberry Star Bread

Gingerbread Mug Cake

Pumpkin Cranberry Crackers

20 Delicious & Simple Holiday Cookies

📖 Recipe